The constructivist challenge to structural realism 189 certainty, levels and trends in relative power will thus act as a key constraint on state behavior. The emergence of a shared identity university at albany. Without a credible mechanism for collective identity formation, recognition theory fails to predict fundamental change in the international system. Social theory of international politics may not be an investigation into identity formation wendt, 1999. Media and the development of identity 3 opportunities to explore common adolescent concerns with peers, issues suchassexualityordealingwithparents. Recognition and collective identity formation in international. Also for a critical explanation of neoliberals emphasis on domestic politics in theorizing state interests, see alexander wendt, social theory of international politics cambridge. United states different north korea policies, kim daejungs sunshine policy, and united statessouth koreanorth korea relations. Identity formation and the development of national interest. This article uses psychological theories of identity formation to critically assess the recent move by constructivist scholars most notably alexander wendt to bring. Collective identity formation and the international state alexander wendt yale university t he neorealistneoliberal debate about the possibilities for collective action in international relations has been based on a shared commitment to mancur olsons rationalist definition of the problem as one of getting exogenously given egoists to cooperate.
Alexander wendt on constructivism and the collective. Wendt dedicates an entire chapter to working out the details of how this may occur. Collective identity formation and collective action. Finally, the interaction of complexity, stability, and leadership produces extremely polarized societies. The description of the events leading to, during, and after the popular uprising. Alexander wendt is well known for his writings on constructivist political theory, in which collective identity play a prominent role as identity is a major determining factor in the role of states in the international order. Collective identity formation and the international state american. The author and two female graduate students gained entry based on contacts with local grassroots activists and their networks. Collective identity formation and the international state volume 88 issue 2 alexander wendt skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. The social construction of power politics io 46 1992. Collective identity formation and the international state alexander wendt yale university e neorealistneoliberal debate about the possibilities for collective action in international relations has been based on a shared commitment to mancur olsons rationalist definition of x the problem as one of getting exogenously given egoists to cooperate. The impact of european and national identity construction. Wendt himself, drawing his theoretical approach from other. Wendt argued that the formation of identity and interests was shaped by intensive interaction.
Keywords collective identity, constructivism, hegel, ingroup, recognition, social identity theory, wendt, world state. Setting a reading intention helps you organise your reading. Chapter 3 case study part 1 collective identity formation 112001032006 2. The social construction of power politics, international organization 46, no. Alexander wendt, anarchy is what states make of it. Collective identity formation on the korean peninsula. The concept of state identity in international relations citeseerx. Collective identity, collective interest, and collective action. Social theory of international politics guillaume nicaise.
Under this debate, however, both of them shared mancur olsons definition of collective problem, which regard selfinterested. This article analyzes issues relating to the relationship between human security. Hidemi suganami this volume sees collective identity formation as an idea particularly worth following up. These methods will allow researchers to use identity in a more rigorous and replicable way as an independent and dependent variable in a wide variety of research projects. The concept of state identity in international relations. Without a credible mechanism for collective identity formation, recognition. Katzenstein, emanuel adler, michael barnett, kathryn sikkink, john ruggie, martha finnemore, and others have, within a. Collective identities in world society some theoretical and. Collective identity and structural change 336 master variables 343 interdependence 344 common fate.
Alexander wendt the debate between realists and liberals has reemerged as an axis of contention in international relations theory. In this and later articles, wendt argues that identity formation under anarchy is concerned primarily with the preservation or security of the self. Wendt argues that this is exactly what happens in kantian culture, when states develop collective identity as friends and. A collective identity however reinforces and increases the depth of trust and the more tightly connected security communities are, the shorter is the collective cognitive distance between its members. Centuries of geographical separation were concurrent with the development of diverse. Concepts of security differ in the extent to which. Under anarchy processes of identity formation is concerned with security of the self.
Collective identity formation and the international state volume 88 issue 2 alexander wendt. Wendt 1994 collective identity formation and the intersexual state. This common social knowledge and collective 1 roy allisoned. Hence, the concept of human security is more meaningful when viewed through the theoretical lens of constructivism wendt, 1992. But in light of ir scholars strong interest these days in nonstate actors, domestic politics, and globalization, social theorys concern with states and the states system looks admittedly a. In his research on collective identity formation, constructivist scholar alexander wendt argued that identities define interests and actions. Rituals are the socially essential collective activities within a culture.
Anarchy and by extension power politics are not materialistic in nature but what states make of them. This means that we can speak of collective identity whenever a certain social identity is of overriding importance for the members of a collective, i. Alexander wendt s 1992 article on anarchy is what states make of it placed the question of collective identity into the mainstream of international relations theory. The problem of uncertainty complicates wendt s efforts to show that anar chy has no particular logic, but only three different ideational instantiations in. Pdf alexander wendt on constructivism and the collective. One reason for this concerns the second difference in my approach, which concerns the role of technology.
Wendt s article broke free from decades of realism as the monopoly in. Ringmar found wendt s application of social constructivism to ir theory but not to the philosophy of science puzzling. Wendt, alexander collective identity formation and the. Concerning alexander wendts constructivism, identity and. Wendt and academics such as nicholas onuf, peter j. Third, the simulation reveals that the presence of leaders i. Identity formation, also known as individuation, is the development of the distinct personality of an individual regarded as a persisting entity known as personal continuity in a particular stage of life in which individual characteristics are possessed and by which a person is recognized or known such as the establishment of a reputation. Wendt, alexander 1999 social theory of international politics. Wendt avers that, social constructions are as a result of norms and identities created by the actors in the international arena. Alexander wendt born 12 june 1958 is an american political scientist who is one of the core social constructivist researchers in the field of international relations, and a key contributor to quantum social science. His approach focuses on group and individual identity, at the domestic and international level. The constructivist challenge to structural realism. Irtheoryconstructivismcollective identity formation. Pdf collective identity formation and the international state.
Thus, in the end, this interaction evolved into cooperation, and cooperation evolved into a community. Collective identities in world society some theoretical. Analyzing dissolution factors for asian and pacific council. The social construction of power politics created date. Alexander wendt ohio state university december 2004. Collective identity formation and the international state, alexander wendt. You can filter on reading intentions from the list, as well as view them within your profile read the guide. In his social theory of international politics, wendt 1999 conceptualizes. Identity theorizing in international relations theories springerlink. Pdf collective identity formation and the international. Collective identity formation and the international state authors.
1313 1163 1222 1408 548 282 895 540 1490 388 46 1344 313 847 532 574 328 1128 1275 1517 723 424 1436 975 1192 1444 1171 1479 1345 152 523 1226 474 850 343 474 1057 210 1059 126 59 546